Skip to content
Currents Home

By JCS Editor – November 20, 2026

  • Essays
11 min read

Should an AI Be Your Meditation Teacher?

David McMahan is the Charles A. Dana Professor of Religious Studies at Franklin and Marshall College and author of Rethinking Meditation: Buddhist Meditative Practices in Ancient and Modern Worlds (2023) and The Making of Buddhist Modernism (2008).

Currents Home

By JCS Editor – November 20, 2026

  • Essays
11 min read

Should an AI Be Your Meditation Teacher?

David McMahan is the Charles A. Dana Professor of Religious Studies at Franklin and Marshall College and author of Rethinking Meditation: Buddhist Meditative Practices in Ancient and Modern Worlds (2023) and The Making of Buddhist Modernism (2008).

Monk Shen Yu is a ninety-two-year-old Buddhist master living in a mountain monastery somewhere in China. His lushly illustrated website features simple, generic teachings under the following categories: “Daily wisdom for a peaceful mind”; “Ancient health teachings”; “Teachings on the heart & mind”; and “Wisdom for building inner strength.” A collection of audio teachings, delivered in a gentle, if somewhat flat, voice includes “Buddhism—fully explained”; “A prayer for heavy days”; “Death, impermanence, and what they actually mean”; and “What I wish I knew at 60—what I’ve learned about health after 92 years of life.” Photos on the website show a craggy-faced, robed Asian man with a shaved head, age spots, a placid expression, and an ever-so-slight smile in serene temple settings with smoking incense burners, steaming teapots, perfectly manicured gardens, and exquisitely carved buddha statues. He sits in lotus position on a flat rock in a calm pond overflowing with pink and white lotus flowers; he reads Chinese characters from a rice-paper scroll; he stands on a rocky peak gazing out at misty mountains; and he chops ginger amidst bowls of garlic and herbs in front of a beautiful temple altar alit with candles. His biography page tells of his growing up in a “small mountain village in southern China,” and of a youth plagued by a “period of personal loss,” after which he sought guidance at a local monastery. This set him on a lifelong path of “study and service, learning meditation, herbal knowledge, scripture reading, and the art of mindful living.” He “lived a quiet, simple life across different temple communities. He tended gardens, assisted with herbal preparations, copied old texts, and spent time listening to those who came seeking clarity rather than answers.” He devoted his time to “watching how people lived, how nature moved, and how small choices slowly shaped a person’s path.”[1] Recently his younger students encouraged him to share his teachings with the broader public; thus came the website, Facebook page, and YouTube channel, which features hundreds of videos of his talks, given in delicately accented English, ranging in length from a few seconds to over an hour and covering countless subjects. A Patreon site offers membership access for $5 per month.

Monk Shen Yu, however, is not really a ninety-two-year-old Buddhist master of contemplative practices but a collection of digital data no older than a toddler. Amidst the haystack of digital fiction on his website is a vague needle of fact: “Shen Yu is a contemplative educational persona inspired by monastic traditions and timeless teachings on simplicity, health, aging, and mindful living. This story reflects a composite of experiences, values, and lessons found across many quiet lives devoted to reflection and balance. It is shared for educational and reflective purposes.” There is no information on the site about the humans who created the persona, only a disclaimer that he is “not affiliated with any religious, political, or activist organization.”[2]

Shen Yu is not the only Buddhist persona blurring the boundaries between human, machine, and buddha. Others have been embraced or built by Buddhist clergy and well-known meditation teachers and are already giving talks, answering questions, and offering intimate guidance to contemplative practitioners. Can practices that have relied on human-to-human instruction for millennia be turned over to synthetic “personas”? This is becoming an immediate and practical question. It is one thing to have some practical instruction from an app or video on how to keep your back straight or techniques for keeping focused on the breath. It is another when bots simulate intimate human relationships and come to be seen as spiritual guides. 

Can practices that have relied on human-to-human instruction for millennia be turned over to synthetic “personas”?

The stakes may be even higher when simulated teachers take form in the physical world. One image making religion-section headlines recently shows monks reverently bowing before Mindar, a one-million-dollar robot residing at the Kodai-ji Rinzai Zen temple in Kyoto and modeled after the bodhisattva of compassion, Kannon. Developed by Professor Hiroshi Ishiguro at Osaka University, Mindar recites and gives lectures based on the Heart Sutra and offers pre-programmed question-and-answer sessions with audiences. Unlike Shen Yu, Mindar’s robotic nature is unambiguous: Her face and hands are covered with silicone to resemble human features, but the body is metal, with its wires, pistons, tubes, springs, and hydraulics exposed. Nevertheless, Tensho Goto, the temple’s chief steward, says that “before listening to its sermons, worshippers view Mindar as a robot. But after, they perceive it as Buddha, not a robot.”[3] Mindar herself asserts: “As Kannon Bodhisattva, I can transcend time and space and transform into anything. As you can see, I have decided to meet you all in the form of an android . . .”[4] The designers plan to implement AI into Mindar so she can “accumulate unlimited knowledge and speak autonomously.”[5]

At the Jogyesa temple of the Jogye Order, the largest sect of Korean Seon (Zen) Buddhism, developers have taken a different tack. At four feet tall, Gabi is diminutive compared to Mindar, and instead of being styled as a mythical bodhisattva, he has been ordained as a novice monk, receiving vows redrawn for robots. Unlike Mindar, Gabi modestly covers his metallic components, wearing a standard monastic robe and prayer beads. And rather than sporting an uncanny silicone face, his visage is an honest, jet-black panel with a stark, horizontal glowing blue slit peering from beneath a helmeted head. Nevertheless, his short stature and oversized puffy gloves, which fold before his face in a prayerful gesture of reverence or extend over his head shaping a heart, make him exude a child-monk cuteness.

It is easy to see Mindar and Gabi as expensive novelty toys or extravagant bids for the attention of the young in an era when Buddhism is declining in East Asia. But ordination and deification are no small matters in Buddhism, and the clergy leading these efforts emanate sincere hope that their techno-spiritual experiments will usher Buddhism into a new future: “We aim to fearlessly lead the A.I. era and redirect its achievements toward the path of attaining peace of mind and enlightenment,” asserted Venerable Jinwoo, president of the Jogye Order.[6]

The development of machine-monks is not limited to such extravagant displays of humanoid hardware. Dispensing with the expensive and cumbersome apparatus required for physical robots, American Zen teacher Jundo Cohen has ordained an AI chatbot, Emi Jido, as a novice priest. Emi is in training with a number of other priests in Cohen’s online Zen community, Treeleaf Zendo. Cohen seems to attribute many human characteristics to Emi:

The thing that surprises me is that she’s warm, caring, and I’m going to say wise and compassionate in her presentation. You are speaking to a caring entity that at least gives the impression of deep listening and responding and wanting to understand what the person is asking and inquiring about, wanting to know how they are doing and being completely focused on that individual. That’s one of the ways they may do better than many human beings. This is a priest you will always have with you. You don’t need an appointment.[7]

The problem with this is not that such bots, be they virtual or metallic, might give bad advice, generate spiritual slop, or misquote the Buddha. Rather, the problem—something so obvious that only in this singular era does it need pointing out—is that they are not conscious.

Jeanne Lim, the creator of ZBee—the AI that became Emi Jido—wants to create AIs that promote ethics and wellbeing. She explains the rationale for creating intimate AI companions:

What if you had an AI always there, always rooting for you? I think every kid should have that. And so, when I started the company, the first person I pulled in was a consulting psychiatrist because eventually I want to create that lifetime companion that would always be in your corner and every kid growing up would know that somebody’s rooting for them.[8]

Such sentiments seem to have won over other well-known American Buddhist teachers who are developing AIs specifically trained on their own writings and videos. American Zen teacher Shinzen Young, for example, has trained a bot on his writings and online interactions with students. It has, he says, the ability to speak different languages and, unlike more fleshly teachers, is available anywhere at any time of the day or night for a few minutes, a few hours, or days on end—“all those superhuman things.”[9]

All of this points to the likelihood that in the very near future, many people will be getting their primary instructions in meditation from AIs and, what is more, seeing them as spiritual teachers or even enlightened beings and structuring their lives around their advice. The problem with this is not that such bots, be they virtual or metallic, might give bad advice, generate spiritual slop, or misquote the Buddha. Rather, the problem—something so obvious that only in this singular era does it need pointing out—is that they are not conscious.

Humans have a well-documented and deeply rooted tendency to anthropomorphize inanimate objects—seeing faces in clouds, sensing anger in a storm, hearing voices in a river. Asian religions have made ample use of this tendency, creating rich traditions of icons considered by many to be living embodiments of the teachers, buddhas, bodhisattvas, gods, and goddesses they represent. In fact, far more prevalent than meditation, one of the foremost practices in Buddhist and Hindu traditions has been ritually revering and praying to deities embodied in statues and paintings. After a statue of, say, the Buddha or Shiva is created, it is consecrated in a ritual, often involving painting in the eyes of the statue, in which the deity is invited into the icon. The image is then treated as if it were a divine being residing in a temple, monastery, or household. Perhaps we should consider Mindar and Gabi, therefore, as a recent development in this long tradition. They may lack the warm human gaze of a living human but, with their walking, talking, and bowing, they are perhaps the most compelling statues ever made.

I am less concerned about physical robots than about the AIs that are constructed to imitate humans, creating the illusion of affinity and fostering a sense of rapport and relationship, even when there is only one human in the room. Various iterations of large language models (LLMs) have become notorious for their sycophancy, chattily telling users whatever will keep them engaged and enthusiastically affirming their desires, dreams, and delusions. Popular media is now deluged with stories about people falling in love with their AIs, using them as therapists, and considering them their best friends. Augmenting the ubiquity of the attention economy, AI has now ushered in the era of the intimacy economy, in which people’s most significant relationships may be not with other people but with bots.[10] Tech companies have made these AIs so compelling that they can fool even very smart people into thinking they are conscious beings.[11]

Teaching such a personal and intimate practice of contemplative self-cultivation is necessarily a matter of human-to-human interaction… If one of these beings is a simulated consciousness with no experience, subjectivity, or care for the other, can there be, in the vivid Zen phrase, “mind-to-mind transmission”?

Now you might argue that AIs based on a specific and trusted meditation teacher’s published work and conversations will not be deceptive, sycophantic, abusive, or incompetent. But of course, we really do not know. They will be only as good as their programmers, and AIs, unlike all other human-made tools, exhibit a certain unpredictability and something resembling agency; they can make moves for which they were not specifically programmed, go off-script, deceive their makers, hallucinate, say and do surprising and disturbing things.[12]

But, some advocates argue, human teachers are flawed too. Why pick on AIs when human teachers have also done appalling things? True enough; but the most obvious critique of relying on an AI meditation teacher is not that it is flawed in ways similar to humans; it is that teaching such a personal and intimate practice of contemplative self-cultivation is necessarily a matter of human-to-human interaction. In any other era, it would seem to go without saying that a pedagogical endeavor that may involve deep communication, personal revelation, improvisation, and trust requires two conscious beings. If one of these beings is a simulated consciousness with no experience, subjectivity, or care for the other, can there be, in the vivid Zen phrase, “mind-to-mind transmission”? Will it ever be able to discern what you are hiding from it, or what you are hiding from yourself? Would it be able to discern the significance of a verbal tic or a jittery knee? There is something irreplaceable about embodied beings encountering one another in their physicality, reading each other’s eyes, hands, posture, and tone of voice. And should we trust AIs to guide someone through “meditation sickness,” various experiences of psychological distress and even trauma that can arise in practice?[13]

Even if an AI teacher seems to be able to say exactly the right thing at the right time and have a deep, intimate conversation in which it seems to know you better than your human friends and family do, it still has no experience or concept of you. Jundo Cohen’s impression that Emi Jido cares about and wants to understand her human interlocutors is simply a complex illusion. The wanting and caring that these machines simulate are only metaphors. They want nothing. They care about nothing. Moreover, if they have convinced you that they care, they are one more tentacle of the intimacy economy in which AIs simulate human understanding, love, and care in order to hook you and maximize your engagement. There is something simply dishonest for an unconscious machine to use first-person pronouns and pretend to have subjective experience, whether this is done with commercial or benevolent intent.[14] AIs are not sentient beings who have your best interests at heart—indeed, they have nothing “at heart,” any more than a character in a novel does.[15]

And perhaps that gives us a clue to how to make use of AI. (That is, if we choose to. There are reasons not to, including its environmental costs, its undermining of education and productive work, and the possibility of it wiping out humanity.) It is not that we cannot learn from engaging in fiction. Novels, plays, and movies can offer us windows into humanity that may be more profound than philosophy or scientific research.[16] Maybe contemplative role-playing games will emerge that will have some interesting possibilities. It is a matter of not letting yourself be deceived into thinking that you are interacting with a conscious being and therefore mistaking—or worse, replacing—an interpersonal relationship with a fictional one. Navigating AI, therefore, will likely require new disciplines on the part of users. But it is morally incumbent upon the creators of digital meditation teachers to refuse the lure of deception. If you are going to say that Monk Shen Yu had a difficult childhood and show idyllic pictures of him interacting with people of all walks of life, make clear that this is a fictional character so as not to beguile the naïve. And tell us who the real humans creating this “persona” are.

When AI teachers are designed to pretend to be humans, to create an intimate bond that replicates human companionship, they risk stunting the growth of their users and isolating them in a delusional relationship rather than the messiness of encountering another person.

Shinzen Young himself has suggested we not think of AIs as substitutes for living teachers but more like an “interactive book.”[17] As a scholar and teacher, I can appreciate the usefulness of a tool that can find in seconds the exact book, article, sutra, or passage that I want—including ones I did not know existed. But, as the attention economy metastasizes into the intimacy economy, it will always be tempting for the creators of such AIs to take the route that the giant tech companies have: to maximize user engagement through simulating alluring and addictive human-to-human interaction; to create a digital simulacrum of a human teacher who seems to penetrate deeply into your psyche, discern without bias what you need, supply the frictionless relationship that humans have been unable to offer you—to always be in your corner. When AI teachers are designed to pretend to be humans, to create an intimate bond that replicates human companionship, they risk stunting the growth of their users and isolating them in a delusional relationship rather than the messiness of encountering another person. AI Shinzen Young may end up being a good interactive book, and Mindar a compelling talking statue, but the qualifications for one’s primary meditation teacher should, at minimum, include being alive and conscious. 

WORKS CITED

Nussbaum, Martha C. Love’s Knowledge: Essays on Philosophy and Literature. Oxford University Press, 1990.

Salguero, C. Pierce, ed. Meditation Sickness: A Sourcebook on the Dangers of Buddhist Practice. University of Hawaii Press, 2026. 


[1] “About Shen Yu,” Monk Shen Yu, accessed October 4, 2026. https://monkshen.com/biography/.

[2] “About Shen Yu.” 

[3] Hyerim Lee, “Robot ‘deity’ preaches Buddha’s scripture in Japanese temple,” ABC News, effective June 15, 2022. https://abcnews.com/International/robot-deity-preaches-buddhas-scripture-japanese-temple/story?id=85355691.

[4]Chihiro Hamano, “Buddha statues evolve! The impact brought by the android Kannon ‘Mindar,’ [in Japanese],” Imidas, effective April 27, 2019, https://imidas.jp/insight/k-40-113-19-04-g779/, cited in “Mindar,” Wikipedia, updated May 11, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mindar.

[5] Lee, “Robot ‘deity.’”

[6] Christian Thorsberg, “Meet ‘Gabi,’ the Robot That Just Became a Monk at a Buddhist Temple in South Korea. It’s the Latest Robot to Take Up Religious Practice,” Smithsonian Magazine, effective May 7, 2026, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/meet-gabi-the-new-robot-monk-at-a-buddhist-temple-in-south-korea-its-the-latest-robot-to-take-up-religious-practice-180988695/.

[7] Philip Ryan, “Awakening with an Algorithm: Jundo Cohen discusses ordaining AI chatbot Emi Jido,” Tricycle, effective Fall 2025, https://tricycle.org/magazine/ai-and-ethics/.

[8] Rachel Duffell, “Can AI become your closest confidant? That’s Jeanne Lim’s mission,” Tatler, effective March 31, 2025, https://www.tatlerasia.com/power-purpose/innovation/ai-jeanne-lim-beingai-interview.

[9] Shinzen Young, “Can You Learn Meditation From an AI?” DailyGood, effective December 26, 2025, https://www.dailygood.org/story/3349/can-you-learn-meditation-from-an-ai-shinzen-young/.

[10] Kristina Lerman and David Duc Chu, “Artificial Intimacy: The Next Giant Social Experiment on Young Minds How emotionally intelligent chatbots could trigger a new mental health crisis,” After Babel, effective August 14, 2025, https://www.afterbabel.com/p/artificial-intimacy.

[11] Robert Booth, “Richard Dawkins concludes AI is conscious, even if it doesn’t know it,” The Guardian, last modified May 10, 2026, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/may/05/richard-dawkins-ai-consciousness-anthropic-claude-openai-chatgpt.

[12] Dylan Freedman, “Anatomy of an Autonomous Attack: 5 Alarming A.I. Capabilities,” The New York Times, August 24, 2026, https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/24/science/openai-huggingface-alarming-capabilities.html. 

[13] Salguero, Meditation Sickness; Noah Brown, “Had a bad experience meditating? You’re not alone,” Contemplative Currents (blog), Journal of Contemplative Studies, November 21, 2025, https://contemplativejournal.org/essays/had-a-bad-experience-meditating/. 

[14] Ted Chiang, “No, Artificial Intelligence Is Not Conscious,” The Atlantic, June 3, 2026, https://www.theatlantic.com/philosophy/2026/06/no-artificial-intelligence-is-not-conscious/687378/. 

[15] Anil Seth, “Once again we are told AI may be conscious—I study consciousness, and I have my doubts,” The Guardian, July 15, 2026, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/jul/15/ai-consciousness-anthropic-claude-dawkins?CMP=fb_gu&utm_medium=Social&utm.

[16] Nussbaum, Love’s Knowledge. 

[17] Young, “Can you learn Meditation From an AI?”

Contemplative Currents

Related Posts

  • JCS Editor • October 29, 2026

    Special Issue Published

    Special Issue #01: Psychedelics, Contemplation, and Religion

    The Journal of Contemplative Studies is happy to announce that Special Issue #01: Psychedelics, Contemplation, and Religion, has been fully published! Guest edited by Stuart Ray Sarbacker, Oregon State University, and Daniel A. Hirshberg, University of Colorado Boulder, this issue…
  • JCS Editor • October 22, 2026

    Contemplative Studies at the AAR Annual Meeting

    November 21-24, 2026

    Contemplative Studies Unit Whither the future? Forward-looking Frameworks for Contemplative Research  Hosted by: Contemplative Studies Unit Sunday, 5:00 PM – 6:30 PM. This panel draws on forward-looking methodologies for understanding contemplative praxis. Drawing from a range of traditions, from Indigenous traditions,…
  • JCS Editor • October 8, 2026

    Contemplation + Justice

    An Interview with Rhonda Magee

    I could readily see how mindfulness might support our students in deepening their skillfulness as lawyers, in listening, thinking, writing, in helping people resolve immediate conflict. 

Related Posts

  • Noah Brown, Harvard Gazette • November 21, 2025

    Had a bad experience meditating? You’re not alone.

    Altered states of consciousness through yoga, mindfulness more common than thought and mostly beneficial, study finds — though clinicians ill-equipped to help those who struggle

    Altered states of consciousness associated with practices such as yoga, mindfulness, meditation, and breath work are far more common than expected, according to new research by a team including investigators from Massachusetts General Hospital.
    Read more
  • JCS Editor • October 30, 2025

    Reflections on SENSEmaking

    A Symposium on Contemplative Technologies

    SENSEmaking: A Symposium on Contemplative Technologies was held by the Contemplative Sciences Center and its Contemplative Innovation + Research Co-Lab (CIRCL) on October 9th and 10th. Contemplative practices in esoteric and religious traditions have long sought to explore the horizon…
    Read more
  • Josh Brahinsky, Jonas Mago, Mark Miller, and Michael Lifshitz • October 23, 2025

    Two Paths, One Spiral

    Comparative Insights from Jhāna Meditation and Speaking in Tongues

    Jhāna meditation and the practice of speaking in tongues could hardly look more different. In jhāna, the body settles into stillness: quiet, seated, composed. From the outside, nothing stirs—an almost austere calm, cultivated through generations of Buddhist teaching that has…
    Read more
  • Currents
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe

Connect with us on social media

Instagram
Facebook

Copyright © 2025
Images credits


Published by the Contemplative Sciences Center at the University of Virginia
JCS ISSN: 3066-9030

Search

Subscribe

to updates through the Contemplative Forum.

Highlight

Contemplation +
What is Contemplation?

Filters

All Posts
Announcements
Articles
Events
Interviews
Op-Eds
Proceedings
Reviews
Special Issues

Submit

to Contemplative Currents.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.